Critique checklist
How to read a proof, and which parameter fixes each problem. Punchcutter runs this list on every draft; you can too.
Open proof.png (or ask Punchcutter to show the proof) and go through this list. If you work in a chat, describe the problem in plain words instead, for example "the a looks clogged in Bold"; the fixes below are what Punchcutter will change. For each problem, the usual fix follows.
Colour and rhythm (the text block)
- Even grey? Squint at the paragraph. Dark clumps or pale holes mean spacing trouble.
Clumps everywhere: raise
spacing. Holes around round letters: lowero_ratioor raisespacingslightly. - Does it read at 20px? If letters fill in, raise
aperture, raisexh, lowerstem. - Word shapes distinct? If a, e, c, o look alike, raise
apertureor switchato"double".
Spacing strings
nnnonnoon: the gaps between n-n, n-o and o-o should feel equal. They are computed, so a mismatch usually means an extreme proportion; moveo_ratioandn_ratiocloser together.HHHOHHOOH: same test for capitals.- Figures should sit a little looser than letters.
Kerning
AVATAR,To,LT,Ty: no gaps, no collisions. Too tight: lowerkerning(0.8). Too loose: raise it (1.15).- Punctuation after r, y, T, F, P should tuck in without touching.
Individual letters (use the glyph command)
- a, e, s in the heaviest weight: counters must stay open. If they clog: lower
weight_compless (letters need width), raiseaperture, or lower the heaviest weight inweights. - Joins of n, m, b, p: a dark knot at the join means
joinis too high for that weight. - S and s: should not lean. If top-heavy, redraw with a custom glyph.
- g, y, j descenders: enough depth to read; deepen
descif cramped. - Round vs flat alignment: o should pass the baseline slightly. If round letters look small, raise
overshoot. - Capitals vs lowercase: capitals should look only a little darker. Adjust
cap_stem.
Family
- Each weight should be clearly different from its neighbours.
- The lightest weight must still hold together; the heaviest must not clog.
- Proportions should feel related across weights.
Character
- Does the proof match the three adjectives from the brief? If it looks generic, pick two or three letters and give them a custom drawing, or push one parameter further than is comfortable.